‘All Asian people need to die’ text message sparks uproar at US university
- School authorities at Occidental College in Los Angeles are under fire for not disciplining a student who blamed Asians for the Covid-19 pandemic
- Chalk messages written by students to protest against the racist texts were erased by campus staff
In late 2020, a student at Occidental College in the US sent a text message to a friend that read: “all asian people need to die.”
She followed with another text saying Asians are “responsible for the pandemic so they need to die for that too”.
A year later, in October or November, the friend reported the text exchange to Occidental officials and her sorority, setting off a controversy that has roiled the small liberal arts college in Los Angeles, as students question what they see as a delayed and inadequate response from the administration.
On Tuesday, after a crescendo of complaints, Occidental College President Harry J. Elam said the student who sent the racist texts is no longer enrolled at the school and has “expressed remorse and regret for her actions”.
01:43
San Francisco steps up policing in Asian-American communities ahead of Lunar New Year
Elam also promised to convene a series of campus forums and anti-bias workshops.
Marty Sharkey, Occidental’s vice-president of communications and institutional initiatives, could not say why the student left the school. The student was not disciplined over the text messages, Sharkey said in an email.
The student who wrote the texts did not respond to requests for comment.
The events at Occidental have raised questions about how to address expressions of hate at universities, especially when communicated in private conversations.
Woman shoved into path of New York train had spent years helping homeless
A campuswide email from Elam on February 3, in which he condemned the texts but said the college was restricted by a state law protecting First Amendment rights at private schools, drew the ire of some students who wanted their peer to be held accountable.
“It angers me that it took the entire student body feeling hurt and harmed” for the administration to acknowledge the messages, senior Shanna Yeh said.
Anaise Nugent, a junior, received the racist text messages more than a year ago. She initially did not share them because she wanted to give her friend a chance to do better, she said.
But, Nugent said, the friend made other discriminatory and offensive remarks, once saying she thought the recruitment of black athletes took away spots from others like herself.
“I tried to give her an opportunity to learn from it, and she never did,” Nugent said.
I didn’t barge into these meetings asking for the student to be expelled. I mainly was looking for accountability
Knowledge of the text messages stayed mostly within the campus administration and the sorority, until someone posted them on Instagram on February 2.
The Occidental chapter of the sorority Kappa Alpha Theta, to which both students belonged, has been thrown into turmoil.
Chapter leaders decided to expel the student who sent the messages, said Elizabeth Frissell, president of Kappa Alpha Theta’s Occidental chapter in 2021.
But the sorority’s national leaders opposed the expulsion, citing a by-law stating that members cannot be punished for actions before joining the group. The student joined the sorority last fall, after she wrote the messages.
Ivy League professor may face sanction over repeated anti-Asian comments
Now, the Occidental chapter will vote on whether to disband because of members’ disappointment over the regional and national leadership.
Kappa Alpha Theta deeply regrets “that people were harmed by the hateful words of an individual previously associated with our organisation,” the national organisation’s chief marketing officer, Julianne Butler, said in a statement.
Yeh, a member of Kappa Alpha Theta who is half Chinese, said she felt brushed off when she reported the texts to the college administration – especially at a time when anti-Asian hate crimes are on the rise.
“I didn’t barge into these meetings asking for the student to be expelled. I mainly was looking for accountability,” Yeh said. “I was looking for accountability in the form of recognition of the harm caused and how violent the language used was.”
Last week, chalk messages written by students to protest against the racist texts were erased by campus staff. Elam later said erasing the messages was a mistake.
Also last week, in the Feb. 3 email to the campus community, Elam said he was “sickened and saddened” by the text messages, which he said he saw for the first time the previous day.
To explain why the school had not taken punitive action against the student, he cited California’s Leonard Law, which gives students at private colleges free-speech rights similar to those at public institutions.
“As difficult as it may be to reconcile, a private text conversation, which is not targeted at an individual and does not represent a credible threat, does not necessarily constitute unlawful harassment,” he wrote.
US House candidate calls for China students to be banned in Texas
Because the texts were not directed at a particular Asian-American student and did not meet the legal definition of a threat, they are constitutionally protected free speech, said Ken White, a First Amendment litigator at the law firm Brown White & Osborn in Los Angeles.
White, who has three Asian-American children, including a daughter who attends Occidental, said he understands the outrage, especially given the anti-Asian racism of recent years. “But legally, it’s not a close call,” he said.
Still, students such as Emily Driscoll, a senior and a member of Kappa Alpha Theta, said the college should have done more earlier.
“If people knew about this when the instance occurred, there would have been a lot less anger,” she said. “But the situation went unknown for the community for months, and it felt like the university was trying to sweep this under the rug.”
