Advertisement
Advertisement
South China Sea
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Filipino fishermen march towards the Chinese consulate during an anti-China protest in Manila on June 11. Photo: AFP

Defiant Filipino fishermen avert South China Sea detention threat ‘by God’s grace’

  • Chinese patrols have ‘gotten stricter’ since Beijing passed its anti-trespassing law, the fishermen say
Filipino fishermen continue to find themselves at the sharp end of the long-running South China Sea row between Manila and Beijing, with tensions showing no signs of abating and the Chinese coastguard stepping up patrols close to Philippine waters.

Last Tuesday, the fishermen of Masinloc town in Zambales province spotted Chinese vessels some 30 nautical miles (56km) off the coast.

Members of the local fishing community say they have witnessed a noticeable increase in Chinese patrols since June 15, when Beijing enacted a regulation empowering its coastguard to detain foreigners for trespassing into what it considers its maritime territory in the South China Sea.

“We continue to fish. This is not a new occurrence. The Chinese coastguard and militia have been doing this for a long time,” Leonardo Cuaresma, president of the New Masinloc Fisherman’s Association, told This Week in Asia.

“By God’s grace, they haven’t detained any fishermen even if their patrols have gotten stricter,” Cuaresma said.

Still, Filipino fishermen continue to exercise caution when venturing out into the waters surrounding Scarborough Shoal, long a traditional fishing ground located some 124km west of Masinloc. It and the similarly disputed Second Thomas Shoal have long been flashpoints in the ongoing territorial dispute between the Philippines and China.
A Filipino fisherman waves a Philippine flag aboard a wooden boat as they sail towards Scarborough Shoal in May. Photo: EPA-EFE
Both sides have levelled mutual accusations of trespassing on their territories. The latest clash on June 17 at Second Thomas Shoal resulted in several Philippine navy sailors being injured, including one who lost a thumb. Chinese coastguard personnel were also accused of seizing firearms and damaging lifeboats on a Philippine vessel, which was resupplying troops on a remote military outpost at the shoal.

Ahead of the implementation of Beijing’s new anti-trespassing regulation, fishermen’s groups in the Philippines threatened to kidnap Chinese nationals as retaliation for every Filipino detained by China.

“The fishermen who have been catching fish around Bajo de Masinloc have been affected the most,” Cuaresma said, referring to Scarborough Shoal by its Filipino name. “No one can get close to the payao [a traditional device for attracting fish] to harvest their catch, as the Chinese coastguard patrols as far as 40 nautical miles from Bajo de Masinloc.”

“As [the fishermen’s] leader, when we talk, we continue to remind them that even if no one has been detained yet, they need to exert extra caution. That’s the only thing we can do for them, we can’t stop them from going out to sea as we won’t be able to support their livelihoods,” Cuaresma said.

As more fishermen have turned to deep-sea fishing, venturing up to 20 to 30 nautical miles (37km-56km) off the shores of Zambales is not uncommon.

Meanwhile, observers have noted increased Chinese patrols within the West Philippine Sea, Manila’s name for those parts of the South China Sea that includes the country’s exclusive economic zone.

Foreign policy and security analyst Lucio Pitlo said live-fire exercises earlier this month between the Philippines and the United States off the coasts of Ilocos Norte and Zambales might have provoked a response from China, including the deployment of its 165-metre coastguard ship, nicknamed “The Monster”, to patrol disputed areas in the region.
Under the pretext of responding to actions that may undermine its interests … Beijing is upping the ante
Lucio Pitlo, security analyst

“China is showing that such joint military drills no longer deter it. Under the pretext of responding to such actions that may undermine its interests in the hotspot, Beijing is upping the ante against Manila, including in Ayungin Shoal,” he said, referring to Second Thomas Shoal by its Filipino name.

Joshua Espena, vice-president of the International Development and Security Cooperation think tank, said China was testing the limits of the Philippines’ newly introduced Comprehensive Archipelagic Defence Concept.

“Its logic means closing gaps in defending the archipelago’s internal waters and adjacent exclusive economic zone while having the Americans fill some of these gaps through the Enhanced Defence Cooperation Agreement,” he said.

“China is currently trying to provoke us by testing its limits close to our territorial waters,” said Don McLain Gill, a geopolitical analyst and lecturer at De La Salle University’s Department of International Studies. “It seeks to create any form of controversy it can use to its favour in the context of active escalation.”

Following the clash on June 17, Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Enrique Manalo said his department was working towards bringing China back to the negotiating table.

Chinese coastguard personnel confront Philippine Navy personnel near Second Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea. Photo: AFP

He told a Senate panel on Tuesday that the Philippines was seeking a peaceful resolution to the bilateral dispute through international law and diplomacy.

“Of course, we are not blind to the incidents which are happening, and we will ensure that whatever confidence-building measures we achieve, they will be not at the expense of the promotion of our sovereignty, sovereign rights as well as our rights and jurisdiction in the West Philippine Sea,” Manalo said.

Cuaresma said he and his fellow fishermen trusted that the Philippine authorities would keep them safe, adding that the community had heard from officials including Philippine Navy Inspector General Commodore Roy Vincent Trinidad.

“Commodore Trinidad gave a promise that they will continue to watch over the fishermen and they will always be there for support, with three patrols around Bajo de Masinloc, while the rest are scattered around Palawan,” he said.

“As our armed defence at sea is weaker, there is nothing we can do.”

23