Advertisement
India
This Week in AsiaHealth & Environment

India’s ‘rathole’ tunnel rescue spotlights dangers of Himalayan infrastructure work

  • The workers’ 17-day ordeal in a tunnel in Uttarakhand is just the latest in a string of accidents and disasters in the ecologically sensitive region
  • Experts caution that development work should be done in consultation with teams of scientists, geologists and engineers to minimise disasters

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The entrance of the under-construction Silkyara tunnel that caved in is seen in the Uttarkashi district of India’s Uttarakhand state on Wednesday. Experts say the region’s fragile geology makes tunnels such as this one prone to collapse. Photo: AFP
Biman Mukherji
The rescue late on Tuesday of 41 workers from a collapsed tunnel in the Himalayas after a 17-day ordeal should serve as a wake-up call for authorities in India to proceed with caution on any construction work in the disaster-prone region, environmentalists say.

“The government should audit and review the construction quality of all tunnels in the Himalayas. Once they are opened, they will also be prone to jerking and shaking movement due to the traffic,” said Yashpal Sundriyal, a geology professor at the Hemwati Nandan Bahuguna Garhwal University in northern India’s Uttarakhand state, where the under-construction tunnel is located.

“The geology of the tunnel which is being constructed is on weak rocks. When we are constructing anything in such a zone, we will have to take extra care,” he added.

03:04

‘Rat miners’ to the rescue: how trapped tunnel workers were saved in India

‘Rat miners’ to the rescue: how trapped tunnel workers were saved in India

India’s mountainous northern regions are prone to shearing – the deformation of rocks as they move against each other – which makes them highly vulnerable to fragmentation and collapse, according to Sundriyal.

Advertisement

He said the main reason that the tunnel caved in was that the support systems needed to ensure stability were not installed before the construction team commenced work.

Indian authorities had to deploy “rathole” miners, who are adept at burrowing in tight spaces but whose profession is effectively banned in the country, to free the workers after repeated attempts to use heavy machinery failed.

The workers became trapped under 60 metres of rubble when a landslide caused a portion of the Silkyara tunnel – part of a US$1.5 billion project to connect key Hindu pilgrimage sites spread across some 890km – to cave in.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x