bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Maria Siow

A baby was killed by a metal ball that fell from a multistorey apartment block, and despite a door-to-door investigation by the police, the perpetrator has not been found.
So how can justice be served?
The answer, in the case of Suining city in China’s southwestern Sichuan province: make every household in the block pay 3,000 yuan (US$439) to the baby’s family.
The controversial decision, which has stirred public debate, came four years after the incident occurred in November 2016.
On that fateful day, Madam Li was pushing her 12-month-old daughter “Yanyan” (a pseudonym) – in a pram along a street in Suining when a metal palm-sized ball – the sort used for hand exercises – dropped out of a nearby building, hitting the baby.

“There were no cries from the child, who quickly became unconscious,” local media reported.
Yanyan was rushed to hospital but died that night, a week short of her first birthday.
In videos making the rounds on the internet, the girl’s mother says she was so devastated she initially lost the will to live. However, thoughts of catching the killer and getting justice for her child kept her going.
For a month, Yanyan’s parents – identified by their family name Zhou – searched for clues in the vicinity of the apartment block, asking residents for tips.
When no one came forward as the owner of the ball, the couple sued everyone in the block and settled in to wait as the case passed through the legal system.
Snail Awards bring slow progress in China’s fight against bureaucracy
Yanyan’s father was 44 at the time of the incident and her mother was 41. They had married only the year before Yanyan’s death and went on to have another child a year after.
Late last month, the Chuanshan local district court ruled that all households in the eight-storey block – except the vacant apartments – shared culpability, and ordered them to pay compensation jointly.
It said that under Article 87 of the Liability Law, the presumption of guilt applied to “disputes over liability for damage from unidentified thrown objects and falling objects”.
“As long as the owner or the user of the house cannot prove that he is not at fault, he is presumed to be at fault,” the court said.
“Although only one person could have committed the infringement, the law should protect the weak and balance the interests of all parties. This can achieve the purpose of comforting the victims and serve as a warning to the public,” it added.
Many Chinese internet users questioned the judgment, saying that while the family deserved justice it was unfair to hold all the households responsible.
Others questioned why the court had been so hasty in issuing a verdict, considering there were “countless unsolved crimes in China”.
One user said: “Anyone who admits to throwing the ball might have to pay compensation of up to a million yuan and face a jail sentence. But denying it till the very end means that everyone, including the perpetrator, only has to fork out 3,000 yuan. Who in their right mind would admit guilt?”
Another said: “The court is simply taking the easy way out. The perpetrator is a murderer and should not be let off so easily.”
Others criticised the police for failing to find the culprit, some wondering why fingerprinting the ball had not worked and pointing out that the balls usually came in pairs and tended to be used by elderly men.
In China, it is common to see men of middle age and above juggling a pair of metal balls in their palms. Many believe the balls help relax muscles, calm nerves, boost circulation, improve sleep, and even lower blood pressure.

Some internet users said more surveillance cameras were needed, while one said the court should have ordered every household to pay 10 times as much as doing so would “induce everyone living in the building to provide clues and conduct a more thorough investigation leading to the eventual arrest of the culprit”.
Other concerns were more practical: what if the culprit was eventually found? Would households be refunded the compensation, presumably from the perpetrator?
Another pointed out that the ball might have been pushed out of the window by a pet dog or cat.
Some households have vowed to appeal the court’s decision, with a few saying they could prove nobody was home at the time.
Think telemarketers are a pest? Wait till China’s AI versions call
The Beijing News blasted the verdict as “second-rate justice” and said police should continue to seek the real culprit.
Zhang Xingjin, a lawyer with the Shandong Qilu Law Firm, said that in applying the law, the focus appeared to be on extending sympathy to the victims and protecting public safety.
“Although it appears unfair, it is probably the most humane approach for now.
“At the very least, it will force everyone – residents and building managements – to exercise greater caution, and promote the improvement of safety measures and regulations in local neighbourhoods,” Zhang said.
The law may have been applied and justice served, but it is cold comfort to both those who must fork out for a crime they did not commit and Yanyan’s parents, who are still awaiting closure.
As Yanyan’s father pointed out: “No matter what, nothing will bring my baby girl back to life.” ■


Shock as China boy grabs girl in lift, drags her away, is arrested then freed

China abductee reconnects with family after 34 years, is quickly estranged again over money

China dad criticised for not holding school bullies accountable after daughter bled from mouth

Many in China deeply moved by boy whispering ‘I love you’ as his mum lay dying from cancer

Children in China

In China, an exercise ball kills a baby and everyone in the block is punished

Yanyan. Photo: Internet

The ball that killed Yanyan. Photo: Internet

Baoding balls. Photo: Shutterstock

Snail Awards bring slow progress in China’s fight against bureaucracy

Image: Shutterstock

Recipients of the Snail Awards.

Coverage of the Snail Awards on WeChat.

Think telemarketers are a pest? Wait till China’s AI versions call

AI bots can make up to 3,000 calls a day, even to blocked numbers.

A woman listens to her mobile phone while holding another one in hand in Causeway Bay. 05JAN17 SCMP/Xiaomei Chen

A man is reflected in a window while using a smart phone in Hong Kong, China, on Wednesday, Nov. 22, 2017. Hong Kong's benchmark equity gauge rose above the 30,000 level for the first time in a decade as Tencent Holdings Ltd. extended its rally and Chinese financial shares climbed. Photographer: David Paul Morris/Bloomberg

This Week in Asia

Health & Environment

News

China

People & Culture

Asia


Yanyan died after a metal palm-sized ball fell from a multistorey building
The owner has never been found, but justice – of a sort – has been served: everyone in the building has been ordered to chip in for the compensation



Yanyan died after a metal palm-sized ball fell from a multistorey building. The owner has never been found, but justice – of a sort – has been served.


Safety in China

Internet

In China, an exercise ball kills a baby and everyone in the block is punished

Yanyan died after a metal palm-sized ball fell from a multistorey building The owner has never been found, but justice – of a sort – has been served: everyone in the building has been ordered to chip in for the compensation

Yanyan died after a metal palm-sized ball fell from a multistorey building

The owner has never been found, but justice – of a sort – has been served: everyone in the building has been ordered to chip in for the compensation