‘Then the crying stopped’: Father allegedly walks into pond with infant son, drowning him as crowd watches
Like James Stewart in Hitchcock’s Rear Window, Robert Amstadt watched the atrocity from his Milwaukee apartment in horror.
It was “the most evil thing I’ve ever seen,” he later told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
Amstadt had heard the telltale signs of a domestic disturbance - voices rising in heated, passionate argument - around 8.45pm Saturday night. It was like any other fight between lovers, until he heard a woman scream: “Give me back my baby.”
Curious, he rushed to the window only to find his view obscured by a patch of trees lining the large pond that residents of both complexes enjoyed. Before Amstadt turned away, a man carrying an infant walked out from between the trees and continued down an asphalt path toward the water.
A cluster of people followed the man in a bewildering parade, yelling: “Don’t go in the water.”
“It was a hornet’s nest of people moving around . . . crying and screaming,” Amstadt told the Journal Sentinel.