Advertisement

Hypocrites and robots: Hong Kong lawmaker slams pro-establishment camp after losing vote calling for legislature to hold own hearings on rail scandal

  • Civic Party lawmaker vents frustration after motion to investigate Sha Tin to Central line is voted down
  • Result came despite transport minister admitting the HK$97.1 billion project had been poorly managed

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Civic Party lawmaker Tanya Chan did not try to hide her frustration after the vote. Photo: Nora Tam

Hong Kong pro-democracy lawmaker Tanya Chan has blasted pro-establishment rivals as hypocritical robots after they voted down a motion to investigate the scandal-hit Sha Tin to Central rail line, despite the city’s transport minister admitting the HK$97.1 billion (US$12.4 million) project had been poorly managed.

Advertisement

Thursday’s proposal from the Civic Party lawmaker was the fourth time the pro-democracy camp has called for the Legislative Council to hold its own hearings into the scandal, even though a commission of inquiry is ongoing.

Afterwards, in response to a question about what she thought of the pro-government lawmakers who voted against the motion, Chan said they were “hypocrites”.

“They may be scolding the government in their speeches, but they vote in a robotic manner,” she said.

The motion had called for Legco to set up a select committee with the power to summon witnesses and request documents from companies and individuals involved.

Advertisement
Tanya Chan’s motion got majority support in the geographical constituency, but failed to pass the functional constituency. Photo: Edward Wong
Tanya Chan’s motion got majority support in the geographical constituency, but failed to pass the functional constituency. Photo: Edward Wong
loading
Advertisement