customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

summary

updatedDate

knowledgeQuestion

disableOffPlatformContent

published

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Brian Wong

A domestic helper has lost a HK$1.06 million (US$135,76o) claim against a retired doctor for alleged sexual assaults during her employment after a Hong Kong court found her allegations to be “bursting with inherent improbabilities”.
The District Court ruled on Tuesday the plaintiff’s “improbable, unimaginable and illogical” assertions outweighed the defendant’s inconsistent and self-contradictory account of the events spanning eight months in 2018 and 2019.
The Filipino worker, who was 40 at the time, testified to being assaulted under the guise of a medical check-up in September 2018, when Brian Drew Apthorp allegedly removed her clothes and molested her.
The worker claimed Apthorp, who is from Britain, later asked the helper to give him daily massages, during which he would lie naked and masturbate.
The doctor also made the plaintiff whip him on a weekly basis for sexual pleasure and asked her to watch a sex video involving him and two of his previous helpers, she claimed.
Deputy Judge David Chan said he was unable to accept the plaintiff’s case due to the manifold discrepancies found in her sworn statements made in court, including in two previous criminal trials in 2020 and 2022 that ended with Apthorp’s acquittal.
Chan noted some key details relating to the claimed body check, including whether the defendant indeed touched her breasts and whether he was wearing gloves when purporting to inspect her genitals, were left out of her written statements.
He also expressed disbelief that Apthorp, who was 80 when the woman began working for him, would engage in sexual activities on almost a daily basis.
Chan said he was dumbfounded by the worker’s willingness to sign the employment contract six days after the alleged assault during the medical check-up, without making any protest, given the supposed risk of being further exploited or even raped by the accused in the future.
Adding to the absurdity was the fact the plaintiff signed the contract without knowing her remuneration and other essential terms, the deputy judge noted.

He also found it inexplicable that she would choose not to tell her friends, church or boyfriend, whom she met once during a visit back to her native country, about the alleged attacks.
“When one looks at the full picture, the plaintiff’s case is bursting with inherent improbabilities,” Chan said.
“Considering the plaintiff’s experiences working as a domestic helper in Hong Kong prior to her employment with the defendant, her working experiences abroad, and her educational background, I do not believe that she would be so innocent, naive, and helpless, to not know her rights, or that she was sexually abused by the defendant, if what she said were true.”
The deputy judge found Apthorp’s account unconvincing either, noting that the latter had provided inconsistent explanations as to the procedure he undertook during the body check on the plaintiff.
Chan said the retired doctor also contradicted himself by denying the use of sexual instruments for self-gratification when he confessed in court to taking a video of himself being whipped by two former helpers.
He also found it ludicrous for Apthorp to deny asking the plaintiff to watch pornography with him with the assertion she had once brought him video clips of sex acts from the Philippines.
Apthorp was jailed for 30 months on two counts of indecent assault arising from the worker’s complaints, but his convictions were quashed upon a successful appeal. A retrial in 2022 ended with his acquittal on all charges.


Former Airport Authority executive pleads guilty to accepting HK$3.3 million in bribes

Hong Kong police chief inspector, wife charged for allegedly taking HK$1.1 million in bribes

Beautician found guilty of helping to provide unlicensed medical services in Hong Kong

Mentally ill Hong Kong woman, 77, pleads guilty to killing husband after suspecting affair

Hong Kong courts

Domestic helper loses million-dollar sexual assault claim against Hong Kong employer

District Court in Wan Chai. Deputy Judge David Chan said he was unable to accept the plaintiff’s case due to the manifold discrepancies found in her statements. Photo: Nora Tam

Retired doctor Brian Apthorp leaves Eastern Court after a criminal case hearing in 2022. Photo: Brian Wong

Hong Kong court clears employer accused of sacking domestic helper over cancer diagnosis

Carla Temporosa holds up pictures of her late friend Joan Guting in front of the latter’s house in Philippines in 2019. Photo: Handout

A Hong Kong court has said it was likely the helper was fired due to her unsatisfactory performance at work. Photo: Nora Tam

Barrister accuses domestic worker of telling Hong Kong court ‘pack of lies’ about rape during cross-examination

A domestic helper testifying at the High Court has been accused of lying. Photo: Warton Li

Defendant Chan Chim-tak (back) leaves the High Court on Wednesday.

News

Hong Kong

Law and Crime

Judge rules plaintiff’s ‘improbable, unimaginable and illogical’ assertions outweighed defendant’s self-contradictory account of events


Judge rules plaintiff’s ‘improbable, unimaginable and illogical’ assertions outweighed defendant’s self-contradictory account of events.
