avatar image
Advertisement

China-India border row: a year after Galwan clash mistrust clouds peace prospects

  • Both sides paid tribute to their soldiers who fought each other with clubs and rocks along the disputed border
  • Risk of conflict persists, charged by misunderstanding and bad sentiment, observers say

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
25
PLA soldiers and tanks disengage along the Line of Actual Control at the India-China border in Ladakh. Photo: Indian Ministry of Defence/AFP
China and India offered tributes this week for the soldiers who died a year ago in a clash over the two countries’ disputed Himalayan border.
In India, the army released a video with a song commemorating the 20 Indian soldiers killed in the confrontation in the Galwan Valley. In China, the Xinjiang military region, which oversees the western border areas with India, arranged a low-key remembrance of its four casualties as part of centenary events for the Communist Party.

While the first anniversary of the deadliest encounter in decades between the Indian and Chinese forces was a chance to remember the lives lost, defence and international relations analysts said it was also time to work together to prevent a recurrence of the incident. But for that to happen, trust needed to be rebuilt on a number of fronts, they said.

02:07

China reveals details of 2020 border clash with Indian troops after both sides complete pullback

China reveals details of 2020 border clash with Indian troops after both sides complete pullback
Chinese and Indian forces have gradually disengaged from the Galwan area since the soldiers attacked each other with clubs and stones a year ago.

There were signs that Beijing was trying to avoid further friction, particularly around the anniversary, said Zhou Chenming, a researcher from the Yuan Wang military science and technology institute in Beijing.

“The low-profile memorial indicates that Beijing doesn’t want to incite national hatred between China and India, a vulnerable wound that has lasted for decades,” Zhou said. “Provoking national hatred will only lead bilateral relations to a dead end.”

However, the risk of conflict persists, according to Deependra Singh Hooda, a retired lieutenant general and former Northern Army commander of the Indian military.

Minnie Chan is an award-winning journalist, specialising in reporting on defence and diplomacy in China. Her coverage of the US EP-3 spy plane crash with a PLA J-8 in 2001 near the South China Sea opened her door to the military world. Since then, she has had several scoops relating to China's military development. She has been at the Post since 2005 and has a master's in international public affairs from The University of Hong Kong.
Advertisement