customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

summary

updatedDate

knowledgeQuestion

disableOffPlatformContent

published

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

A woman in Singapore who defied police instructions when she was being investigated for contempt of court has been sentenced to eight weeks’ jail and fined S$4,200 (US$3,155).
Tarchandi Tan, who changed her name from Lee Hui Yin last year, was previously convicted of five charges, including refusing to attend police investigations or turn up in court and for spitting at the police.
The 53-year-old woman’s troubles began when she allegedly made a ruckus in the trial of anti-masker Briton Benjamin Glynn in August 2021.
She is accused of saying “this is ridiculous kangaroo court” and “I do not respect the judge”.

About a year later, when asked to, she did not show up at a police station for related investigations. She returned all letters sent to her address by mail and refused to engage with police when they knocked on her door.
When she was finally arrested and carried out of her flat, she resisted and spat at the arresting officers.
Tan defended herself without a lawyer. She said she was not obliged to obey any of the orders given to her, as she was a “sovereign individual” and the police had no basis to require her to go to the police station or to court.
The judge rejected this argument, calling it “misconceived” and that the practical effect of the sovereign individual argument is that its proponents are “above the law and can pick and choose what laws they want to obey and to enforce”.
Singapore jails man claiming to be son of a sultan for not wearing a face mask
“This cannot be right. Such an argument is contrary to the rule of law and is a recipe for anarchy,” said the judge.
On Tuesday, District Judge Kow Keng Siong clearly and slowly explained the procedure to Tan and asked her if she wanted to plead guilty to the two remaining charges relating to the “kangaroo court” comment.
He explained the possible implications if she were to plead guilty, or dispute the charges.
Tan vacillated between her positions, initially saying she should plead guilty and “get it over with”. The judge told her that if she did, she would not be able to claim that she was “innocent”.
How can I have remorse when I am innocent? They bruised me. I was molested, kidnapped!
Tarchandi Tan, convicted criminal
Tan was given a few chances to speak with her partner in court about what she wanted to do.
After conferring with her partner about three times, she declared that she would maintain her innocence and contest the two remaining charges.
As a result, the judge proceeded with sentencing her for the first five charges relating to her resistance to the police.
The prosecutor asked for three months’ jail and a fine left to the court.
Singapore jails conscript who deserted to Britain for over 2 decades
Asked to give her mitigation, Tan said: “I already said very clear. On all the charges, I’m innocent. I made my stance very clear. They arrested me with no warrant, they have no body cameras switched on … so I’m innocent.”
She added: “You [the judge] can sentence as you deem fit. God will have the final judgment. When God is done with the fellas upstairs, they’re [going to] have no hair left!”
The prosecutor said this supposed mitigation showed only her lack of remorse.
“How can I have remorse when I am innocent?” Tan said. “They bruised me. I was molested, kidnapped! And I already apologised to the judge for the first two … charges. I already said very clearly there was no crime, no injury, and I did not sign anything, that is why I have no case. The paper that was given to me was not even my name!”
There may be implications of what you say in court that may trigger other actions
District Judge Kow Keng Siong
The judge explained to her what would happen next and tried to tell her about her options when it came to serving jail or paying a fine, but Tan said: “No, I can start serving right away.”
When Tan heard her final sentence, she exclaimed: “Then like that … that means I have to go through again the other sentencing for the first two charges?”
The judge stuck to his line of questioning, asking her if she could pay the fine. Tan said she needed time.
She asked about the number of days jail she would have to serve in default if she did not pay the fine, and was told it would be 21 days.
Singaporean who refused to wear mask says she’s a sovereign. What is that?
“How about – so if I just admit to the first two charges, so we don’t have to go through this bulls***?” she asked.
Judge Kow said: “I advise you to be careful of what you say, and there may be implications of what you say in court that may trigger other actions by whether the police or the prosecutor. You understand what I’m saying, Ms Tan?”
She is expected to return to court for the remaining two charges at a later date.
This article was first published by CNA


Jackson Wang builds a fashion empire – and more – based on ‘easy, casual and fun’ mantra

Turbulence on Scoot flight from Singapore to Guangzhou leaves 7 injured

Singaporean tutor admits using spycam to film his sisters, students in toilets

Southeast Asia reaps rewards as US-China rivalry rocks global supply chains

Singapore

Singapore jails ‘sovereign’ woman who spat at police, resisted arrest: ‘I was molested, kidnapped!’

Tarchandi Tan, who changed her name from Lee Hui Yin last year, was sentenced to eight weeks’ jail and fined S$4,200 (US$3,155) by a court in Singapore for refusing to attend police investigations or turn up in court and for spitting at the police, after claiming to be a “sovereign individual”. Photo: Facebook/Tarchandi Tan

The Merlion statue and Singapore’s financial district as seen from Marina Bay. The judge in Tan’s case advised her to “be careful of what you say” or she may face further legal action. Photo: AFP

Tarchandi Tan was sentenced to eight weeks’ jail and fined S$4,200 (US$3,155) by a court in Singapore for refusing to attend police investigations or turn up in court and for spitting at the police, after claiming to be a “sovereign individual”. Photo: Facebook/Tarchandi Tan

Singapore invokes fake news law against Lee Hsien Yang over Facebook post on political scandals

Lee Hsien Yang, the brother of Singapore’s Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, in June 2020. Photo: AFP

Singapore’s political sagas prompt memes but won’t hurt stability: ‘dark clouds will pass’

Prime Minister Lee, for his part, acknowledged in a press conference on Monday that the PAP was dealing with “a series of high-profile issues”. Photo: via Reuters

Singapore-based Malaysian billionaire Ong Beng Seng was also arrested for a corruption probe. Photo: AFP

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong’s PAP is facing what observers say is a major internal crisis. Photo: Reuters

A combination photo of portraits taken in 2020 shows former parliamentary speaker Tan Chuan-Jin and MP Cheng Li Hui who resigned on July 17 over their “inappropriate relationship”. Photo: via Reuters

Singapore matchmaker ‘preaches the gospel’ in helping Asian men find Vietnamese brides

29-year-old Tien has high expectations for her future husband. Photo: Larissa Ong

A matchmaking scout takes a photo of a potential Vietnamese wife. For 31 years, True Love Vietnam in Singapore has specialised in finding Vietnamese partners for single men, mainly from across Asia. Photo: Larissa Ong

Lin’s scout Phung takes photographs of single Vietnamese women looking for Singaporean husbands to circulate to Lin’s customers. Photo: Larissa Ong

Tien, 29, runs an online cosmetics business. She said she is looking for a man who is “financially stable, and capable of taking care of his wife and children”. Photo: Larissa Ong

A newlywed couple (in red and white), matched by Lin and his scout Phung (left), accompanied by a friend (right). Photo: Larissa Ong

Women wearing the traditional ao dai dress take a picture along the Hoan Kiem lake in Hanoi on October 20, 2021 to commemorate Vietnamese Women’s Day. Photo: AFP 

Singapore passes law cracking down on online content in scams, malicious cyber activity

Singapore’s new legislation targets a range of illicit activities including online scams, spread of misinformation, and use of online platforms for drug trafficking. Photo: EPA-EFE

Singapore’s new legislation targets a range of illicit activities including online scams, terrorism, and use of online platforms for drug trafficking. Photo: Shutterstock 

A person using a smartphone to record a voice message. Singapore’s new legislation is part of its ongoing efforts to tackle crime in the era of the internet and social media. Photo: AFP

Singapore’s new law aims to “strike an appropriate balance between preventing criminal harms and privacy”. Photo: Dreamstime/TNS

News

Asia

Southeast Asia

Tarchandi Tan, formerly known as Lee Hui Yin, claimed she was not obliged to obey any of the orders given to her and did not have to attend court
The judge rejected her argument, calling it ‘misconceived’, adding that picking and choosing what laws to obey was ‘a recipe for anarchy’


Tarchandi Tan, formerly known as Lee Hui Yin, claimed she was not obliged to obey any of the orders given to her and that she did not have to attend court.


Crime

Offbeat

Singapore jails ‘sovereign’ woman who spat at police, resisted arrest: ‘I was molested, kidnapped!’

Tarchandi Tan, formerly known as Lee Hui Yin, claimed she was not obliged to obey any of the orders given to her and did not have to attend court The judge rejected her argument, calling it ‘misconceived’, adding that picking and choosing what laws to obey was ‘a recipe for anarchy’

Tarchandi Tan, formerly known as Lee Hui Yin, claimed she was not obliged to obey any of the orders given to her and did not have to attend court

The judge rejected her argument, calling it ‘misconceived’, adding that picking and choosing what laws to obey was ‘a recipe for anarchy’