bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

TODAY

Three Singapore apex court judges on Wednesday dismissed an appeal lodged by Gaiyathiri Murugayan, who was jailed for 30 years last year for heinously abusing her domestic worker till she died in 2016.
The Court of Appeal hearing on Wednesday afternoon lasted about an hour, with Gaiyathiri repeating her claims of prison authorities and fellow inmates reportedly abusing her, for instance. She sought a shorter sentence of 12 to 15 years’ jail.
Her victim, 24-year-old Myanmar national Piang Ngaih Don, had lost 40 per cent of her body weight and suffered dozens of scars and external injuries from the months-long abuse.
It led to widespread ire from the public and a High Court judge calling it one of the worst cases of culpable homicide to come before the courts.
Starved, beaten with hammer: worst domestic worker abuse cases
Gaiyathiri, 42, appealed against her jail term after pleading guilty to 28 offences.
During sentencing in High Court about a year ago, Justice See Kee Oon said that he would have had “little hesitation” in imposing life imprisonment – as sought by the prosecution – if not for Gaiyathiri’s mental disorders.
She suffered from major depressive disorder and obsessive-compulsive personality disorder, which three psychiatrists agreed had substantially contributed to her committing the offences. Her murder charge was reduced to culpable homicide because of that.

After pleading guilty last year, Gaiyathiri’s then-lawyer’s failed in a bid for a gag order prohibiting further reporting on the case, to protect her children from adverse media publicity.
She has been remanded in prison since July 26 in 2016, when she was arrested on the day of Piang’s death in the family’s three-bedroom flat along Bishan Street 11.
In May, the Court of Appeal rejected her application for medical records in relation to herself and her mother, after she alleged that they had not been given appropriate treatment and care by the prison authorities.
She also asked for records kept by the prison authorities in relation to her complaints about being allegedly abused physically and sexually by fellow inmates.
Abuse, death of Myanmar domestic worker ‘shocking’: Singapore minister
The three judges – Judges of Appeal Andrew Phang, Judith Prakash and Steven Chong – said these records were not relevant in determining whether her plea of guilt was conducted properly or if her sentence was “manifestly excessive”.
On Wednesday, Gaiyathiri rehashed many of these same arguments in a semi-incoherent rant. She appeared via a video-link from prison, with her former lawyer Joseph Chen also present.
The judges had to caution her not to raise these complaints because this was not the appropriate platform to do so. She had spoken about “things at prison … getting from bad to worse”, claiming that prison officers spoke about “gang sex bang” and directed vulgarities at her.
Singapore woman jailed for 30 years for torturing, killing domestic worker
In her written submissions, she raised several other points.
These included assertions that her offences were a result of her psychiatric conditions, as shown by the fact that she had improved to the point of refraining from violence, despite allegedly being bullied or ill-treated, in prison.
She also argued that Justice See failed to consider a diagnosis from Dr Jacob Rajesh, a defence psychiatrist, who had found that she suffered from obsessive-compulsive disorder – a more serious condition than the obsessive-compulsive personality disorder that was diagnosed by the prosecution’s psychiatrist.
She also said that she had felt pressured to be sentenced so that her mother, Prema S Naraynasamy, 61, could be promptly sentenced as well.
Prema and Gaiyathiri’s spouse, suspended police staff sergeant Kevin Chelvam, 42, face 49 and five charges respectively in relation to the abuse. Their cases are before the courts.
Could this scheme put an end to ‘live-in’ rule for domestic workers?
In their judgment on Wednesday, the same three judges said that Gaiyathiri was not allowed to consider Dr Rajesh’s diagnosis in any case.
They said there was also no evidence that the hearing where she pleaded guilty was substantially hastened, because the defence and prosecution had already agreed in December 2018 that proceedings against her would conclude first before Prema’s case proceeded.
The apex court judges said that the stressors Gaiyathiri relied on, including her children’s ill health due to Piang’s supposed bad hygiene, could not provide any excuse for her behaviour.
They agreed with Justice See that she showed a “patent lack of remorse” by seeking to “blame anything and anyone but herself for her offending behaviour”.
She was not prepared to accept responsibility for her actions for a “considerable period” after Piang died, having covered up her role and limited the medical care that the domestic worker received, the judges noted.
Why domestic workers are the modern-day slaves of Asia’s big cities
As for her psychiatric condition, the three judges said that the High Court had already considered this when she was sentenced. In any case, she appeared to be “making good progress” with her treatment, they added.
Her sentence was thus not manifestly excessive, the factors she raised were “wholly without merit” and there was no basis for appellate intervention, they found.
When the hearing concluded, Gaiyathiri said that she will continue to write to Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, adding: “Because it’s my life and my mother’s life. I cannot die here.”
This article was first published on Today Online.


UK lawmakers summon Shein and Temu for questioning over labour practices

Singapore wants to host more mega-events in 2025, boosting regional growth, amid neighbour envy

Hong Kong’s Cathay, Singapore Airlines climb regional punctuality ranking

Hong Kong’s air passenger traffic soars to pre-pandemic levels over Christmas

Singapore

Singapore top court rejects Myanmar helper killer’s appeal against 30-year jail term

Gaiyathiri Murugayan (centre) is escorted from her flat in 2016 after the death of her domestic helper Piang Ngaih Don. File photo: Today Online

Piang Ngaih Don. Photo: Helping Hands for Migrant Workers, Singapore/Facebook 

Could a Singapore scheme for domestic workers be a model for changing Hong Kong’s live-in rule for helpers?

Filipino migrant workers in Hong Kong. Photo: AP

Sampoorna Narayanan. Photo: Handout

Domestic workers gather on a grass patch behind Somerset MRT Station in Singapore.

Women migrant domestic workers march to the Indonesian Consulate General in Causeway Bay, Hong Kong, in a protest for better working conditions. File photo

Domestic helpers in Central, Hong Kong. Photo: Dickson Lee

Starved, beaten with hammer, forced to sleep with dog: worst domestic worker abuse cases of Hong Kong, Singapore and Malaysia

Suyanti Sutrinso. Photo: The Straits Times

Candle light vigil for Adelina and all the victims of human trafficking at Patterson Street in Causeway Bay. Late Adelina Lisao, a domestic worker in Malaysia, was reportedly tortured by her employer. 25FEB18 SCMP / Dickson Lee

ALTERNATE CROP OF XKL801 - In this Feb. 10, 2018 photo, Indonesian house maid Adelina Lisao sits on the porch in Bukit Mertajam, near Penang, Malaysia. The Indonesian maid who allegedly suffered injuries on her body and was forced to sleep outside on a porch with a family's dog has died in Malaysia, prompting calls by activists and lawmakers for better laws to safeguard migrant workers. (AP Photo/Por Cheng Han)

Law Wan-tung, former employer of Indonesian domestic helper Erwiana Sulistyaningsih, is escorted by a staff member from Hong Kong Correctional Services inside a van outside the District Court in Wan Chai. Law Wan-tung, 44, was found guilty of 18 of 20 charges of assault, including two counts of inflicting grievous bodily harm on Erwiana Sulistyaningsih. 10FEB15

Former domestic helper Erwiana Sulistyaningsih meets the media at Kowloon Union Church. Erwiana's former employer (who was jailed for causing Erwiana's injuries) was ordered by the District Court to pay her more than HK$8000,000. 22DEC17 SCMP / Nora Tam

Domestic workers are the slaves of modern Asia. Are Hongkongers, Singaporeans and Malaysians ever going to change?

An activist from the Asian Migrants Coordinating Body holds a placard that reads ‘End Modern Day Slavery in HK’ during a protest on March 8. Photo: AFP

number of domestic workers

Photo: Nora Tam

Different groups of Migrant Domestic Workers join forces in protest for decent wages and resting hours, photographed outside the Harbour Building in Central. Fifteen representatives from two of the most active maids' groups asked for a 24.7% increase in their monthly wage to HK5,500 (the figure shown on the placards at the backdrop). 07AUG18 SCMP / Winson Wong

Indonesian migrant workers attend a May Day rally, also known as Labour Day, in Hong Kong on May 1, 2018. (Photo by DALE DE LA REY / AFP)

Singapore woman jailed for 30 years for torturing, killing domestic worker

Gaiyathiri Murugayan (centre), is escorted from her flat in 2016 after the death of her 24-year-old Myanmar domestic helper Piang Ngaih Don. Photo: Today Online

=== PHOTO CAPTURED ONLINE=== Piang Ngaih Don. Photo: Helping Hands for Migrant Workers, Singapore/Facebook

Hong Kong’s domestic helpers fight through Covid-19 travel restrictions, hectic work hours and substance abuse

Jenalyn Abraham battles Stephanie Ranada Villa at Muay Thai Station in Wan Chai. Photo: Nora Tam

Amateur fighter Jenalyn Abraham with her support crew at the Muay Thai Fighters Club tournament. Photo: Nora Tam   

Goldalyn Wangdali (left) punches Alma Camba Carnazo during the Boxing Day tournament at Muay Thai Station. Photo: Connor Mycroft

Jenalyn Abraham (right) takes a punch from Stephanie Ranada Villa. Photo: Nora Tam

A Muay Thai fighter in her corner during an amateur bout fight on Boxing Day. Photo: Nora Tam   

Aibil Villaluna with her trophy after winning her fight. Photo: Connor Mycroft

Shirly Madalang (left) and Chari Pailanan at the Muay Thai Fighters Club tournament. Photo: Nora Tam 

Nummee Chai and Stefane Romana put in an exhibition fight at Muay Thai Station. Photo: Nora Tam 

News

Asia

Southeast Asia


Gaiyathiri Murugayan, who had repeatedly assaulted Piang Ngaih Don until she died in 2016, sought a shorter sentence of 12 to 15 years
After the judges rejected her appeal, Gaiyathiri said she will continue to write to Prime Minister Lee ‘because it’s my life and I cannot die here’



Gaiyathiri Murugayan, who had repeatedly assaulted Piang Ngaih Don until she died in 2016, sought a shorter sentence of 12 to 15 years.


Myanmar

Crime

Today Online

Women and gender

Singapore top court rejects Myanmar helper killer’s appeal against 30-year jail term

Gaiyathiri Murugayan, who had repeatedly assaulted Piang Ngaih Don until she died in 2016, sought a shorter sentence of 12 to 15 years After the judges rejected her appeal, Gaiyathiri said she will continue to write to Prime Minister Lee ‘because it’s my life and I cannot die here’

Gaiyathiri Murugayan, who had repeatedly assaulted Piang Ngaih Don until she died in 2016, sought a shorter sentence of 12 to 15 years

After the judges rejected her appeal, Gaiyathiri said she will continue to write to Prime Minister Lee ‘because it’s my life and I cannot die here’