avatar image
Advertisement
PostMag
Life.Culture.Discovery.

Destinations known | Why ‘colonial charm’ should not be expunged from the lexicon despite the death and destruction perpetrated by colonisers that it glosses over

  • ‘Colonialism isn’t something to celebrate,’ a travel writer said while making the case that people like him should stop using the term ‘colonial charm’
  • Destinations Known reckons that is going too far. The term draws wealthy tourists from erstwhile coloniser countries, whose spending is a form of restitution

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
2
As beautiful as colonisers’ buildings are, such as the cathedral in the Plaza de Armas in Cusco, Peru, to use the  the term “colonial charm” glosses over the blood spilt and destruction wrought in their creation, a travel writer says. Photo: Shutterstock

“Colonial charm” is a term used often in travel journalism, as shorthand signifying that a building or district has features that date back to a different era, when the land was ruled by a foreign, most likely European power. It’s a term that perhaps appeals most to wealthy Western travellers looking for a hint of something that may no longer be found at home.

Look through the South China Morning Post archives and you’ll find “colonial charm” used to describe the Raffles Hotel in Singapore; parts of Lima, Peru; The RuMa Hotel and Residences, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; the Colaba district of Mumbai, India; the non-gambling parts of Macau; and a “highly desirable” apartment on Hong Kong’s Mount Kellett Road – among many other places and addresses.

Nevertheless, the term is tainted, according to a recent article on the Traveller.com.au website, headlined, “‘Colonial charm’ – the cliché that hides the ugly history of many popular cities”.

The author of the article, Ben Groundwater, begins by recalling a press trip to Peru and Bolivia: “Almost every day we would be viewing historical sites, learning about ancient civilisations such as the Moche, the Chimu, the Nazca, and of course the Inca.

The Raffles Hotel in Singapore – described as having “colonial charm”. Photo: Shutterstock
The Raffles Hotel in Singapore – described as having “colonial charm”. Photo: Shutterstock

“And almost all of these tours would include a similar theme. This place looked like this, the guide would say, describing something incredible, something beautiful, before adding … until the Spanish conquistadors arrived and destroyed it.”

Mark Footer joined the Post in 1999, having been the magazine and book buyer for Tower Records in Hong Kong. He started on the business desk before moving, in 2006, to Post Magazine, of which he was editor until 2019. He took on a secondary role as travel editor in 2009.
Advertisement