Advertisement

Reflections | In decrying ‘foreign interference’, China should remember those times it has meddled in other countries’ affairs

  • Informed by a mix of resentment for past humiliations and pride in recent achievements, China paints itself as the victim of foreign aggression
  • A quick look back at history, however, reminds us of those times the Middle Kingdom was not only aggressor but occupier

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Since protests began in Hong Kong, in June, against the now-withdrawn extradition bill, Beijing has decried ‘foreign interference’. Photo: EPA
The central government in Beijing made up its mind very early on that the ongoing mess in Hong Kong is fuelled to a large extent by “foreign interference”, something to which the Chinese are particularly sensitive, given the nation’s near-capitulation to foreign powers from the mid-19th to the mid-20th centuries.
Advertisement

Informed by a toxic mix of resentment for past humiliations and pride in recent achievements, many mainland Chinese belligerently view the developed world as conspiring to deny their country its rightful place in the sun. However, in constructing the narrative of itself as a victim of foreign aggression and interference in modern times, China may do well to remember that it has, on multiple occasions, interfered in the internal affairs of other nations.

In 1400, the 176-year-old Tran dynasty of Dai Viet, a kingdom occupying the northern half of modern Vietnam, came to a violent end. Ho Quy Ly, a powerful Tran minister, dethroned the child emperor after executing hundreds of people who opposed him, including the emperor’s father, other royal relations and prominent officials. Ho renamed the kingdom Dai Ngu and declared himself emperor of the new Ho dynasty.

When the dust had settled, China had to be informed. Managing relations with its giant northern neighbour had always been a bane for the Vietnamese state, especially when China was strong. Although Dai Viet had been a de facto independent state, the Tran rulers paid fealty to the emperors of the Ming dynasty (1368–1644).

To ensure its security and cement its legitimacy, the newly minted state of Dai Ngu sent envoys to the Chinese court in 1403, where they convinced the Yongle Emperor that Ho’s takeover was legal and enjoyed popular support because they were “blood relations” of the enfeebled Tran royal clan.

Advertisement
A painting of the Yongle Emperor. Photo: Alamy
A painting of the Yongle Emperor. Photo: Alamy
Advertisement