bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Michael Clugston

Flying Blind by Peter Robison pub. Doubleday
Desperation gripped the cockpit of the doomed Boeing 737 MAX airliner over Jakarta, Indonesia, as the sun rose on that October morning in 2018. The chaos had begun mere seconds after the wheels of Lion Air Flight 610 left the ground: alarms sounded; warning lights flashed; the control column shook violently.
The pilot and co-pilot were veteran professionals who had jointly racked up 11,000 hours in older 737 models, before the MAX. Yet this situation was unprecedented; their normal emergency procedures had no effect. The aircraft seemed intent on diving into Jakarta Bay.
The pilots had not rehearsed this emergency in a flight simulator because Boeing had insisted such expensive training was unnecessary. Unlike virtually every other large new commercial aircraft, the MAX lacked touch-screen electronic instructions, so the co-pilot leafed frantically through the inch-thick manual looking for a solution.

His time ran out eight minutes after take-off. Fishermen in the bay watched in horror as Flight 610 streaked almost vertically into the ocean at 800km/h (500mph), killing all 189 people on board.
Five months later, a second Boeing MAX airliner crashed under similar circumstances in Ethiopia. All 157 people on board died.

Journalist Peter Robison recalls those horrific disasters in Flying Blind, his account of Boeing’s increasingly wilful blindness to safety in the decades before the MAX crashes. Global media covered the aftermath extensively: the global MAX fleet grounded for almost two years, US$21 billion in fines and settlements, its CEO fired and its reputation for engineering excellence shredded.
Now Robison’s book takes us on an exploration of the backstory: how a once-great engineering company was hollowed out by senior managers focused on narrow corporate self-interest: profit, in short. He points the finger at a succession of senior executives who steered the company away from its world-leading engineering heritage, enriching themselves and shareholders by buying back massive amounts of the company’s stock.
Robison, a senior reporter with Bloomberg News, has covered the United States aviation industry for decades. He brings a wealth of background knowledge, insider connections and a vivid storyteller’s gift to this often shocking narrative.

The author makes it clear that the MAX crashes were not the inevitable outcome of honest mistakes. They did not need to happen. Boeing knew how to make safe aircraft, such as earlier versions of its 737 and its stellar 777 jetliner, still a poster boy of aviation safety.
So, how did a once-great company fall so low?
The hollowing out of Boeing began in earnest after it acquired the McDonnell Douglas aircraft maker in the mid-1990s, Robison writes. The McDonnell Douglas team were “cutthroat managers trained in the win-at-all-costs ways of defence contracting”. A federal official later described them as “hunter killer assassins” meeting Boeing’s Boy Scouts.

It was essentially a coup, a reverse takeover of Boeing, that imposed new mantras of cost-cutting, slashed investment in product development and the selling off of sophisticated manufacturing plants. Thousands of experienced, dedicated engineers were fired, driving down standards and morale at the once proud company.
Work was increasingly outsourced, often to a cheap bidder with uncertain competence. One Boeing engineer complained that he had to send drawings back to a team in Russia 18 times before they understood that their smoke detectors needed to be connected to an aircraft’s electrical system.
Boeing’s technical decline came amid the fervour for deregulation that began under US president Ronald Reagan. The industry watchdog, the Federal Aviation Administration, was steadily stripped of its powers to enforce safety regulations during aircraft construction, as Boeing convinced Congress that the industry could police itself.

Airbus had surpassed Boeing in 2003 as the world’s largest maker of commercial aircraft, and the American company urgently needed a plane that could compete against Airbus’ successful A320 jetliner. Instead of developing a new aircraft, Boeing decided to rush ahead with production of the MAX, the latest iteration of the old 737 model first built in the mid-1960s.
Boeing piled the pressure on its engineers and production lines, threatening pay cuts if production was interrupted. One engineer commented, “That culture is new, and that culture is toxic,” according to Robison.
Staff morale crumbled as veteran engineers saw their safety concerns disregarded. Rumours swirled among employees about malfunctioning equipment, incorrect parts delivered and missed safety inspections.

In 2018, senior manager Ed Pierson, working on the 737, wrote to his supervisor, “Frankly, right now all my internal warning bells are going off. For the first time in my life, I’m sorry to say that I’m hesitant about putting my family on a Boeing airplane.”
Robison skilfully builds a sense of impending doom as corners are cut to rush the MAX into production. Chief among them was the by-now infamous software system known as MCAS (Manoeuvring Characteristics Augmentation System) that took control of the horizontal stabiliser, the small rear wing, out of the pilots’ hands and nosedived the plane under certain rare circumstances.
MCAS was installed because it was a cheaper, faster fix than using hardware to tame the MAX’s tendency to climb at a dangerously steep angle. But MCAS had a fatal flaw: it could easily be triggered by mistake if one small sensor on the outside of the plane was damaged or misaligned. Faulty sensors sending false information brought down the Indonesian and Ethiopian flights.

Other penny-pinching measures seem almost as shocking in retrospect. Boeing opposed simulator training for pilots on the MAX because of the cost and delays it would entail. When Lion Air asked for pilot training, an arrogant Boeing manager described them privately as “idiots”, and persuaded them it wasn’t necessary – a particularly bitter detail in Robison’s narrative.
After all the investigations and hearings into both crashes, regulators finally ordered Boeing to train MAX pilots in simulators, as well as to repair the MCAS system and update operating manuals. The company paid a criminal penalty of only US$243.6 million – about what it would have cost to train MAX pilots in a simulator, Robison notes.
One veteran pilot commented that Boeing “got away with murder”, and Robison implies that Boeing’s political clout greatly limited the fines and other punishments levied against the company.

The MAX is in many ways a fine aircraft, highly fuel-efficient and economical to operate. Regulators in much of the world cleared the MAX to fly again in June 2021, and China may lift its flight ban by the end of this year.
According to Robison, however, some of the engineers who know the plane best believe the aircraft still needs stronger safety provisions, such as better shielding for its rudder cables. And that paper instruction manual? Robison says the MAX remains the only large commercial airliner without an electronic checklist to guide pilots quickly in emergencies.
Robison has produced an excellent book. If anyone tells you that industry can police itself, you’ll know what to give them for Christmas.


AirAsia’s Tony Fernandes on being ‘loyal to China’, Comac’s allure and Asean expansion

Boeing to cut nearly 2,200 jobs in Washington state, home to many of its oldest factories

With China’s C919 flying high, factory visits aim to replicate Boeing’s branding success

China can be a force in global aviation if Comac rises to challenges

Boeing

How decades of deskilling at Boeing doomed two 737 MAX flights – author dissects the death of its safety culture at the hands of corporate profiteers

Pieces of the wreckage of an Ethiopia Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft near Bishoftu, Ethiopia, March 13, 2019. Journalist Peter Robison marks the fall of Boeing in his book, Flying Blind. Photo: EPA

The cover of Robison’s book.

Robison has covered the United States aviation industry for decades.

A Lion Air passenger jet of the Boeing 737 MAX 8 series at Jakarta Airport. Photo: Getty Images

A Boeing 737 MAX 8 in the company’s factory on March 27, 2019, in Renton, Washington. Photo: Getty Images

Family members of the crashed Indonesian Lion Air Flight 610 at Pangkal Pinang Airport in Indonesia. Photo: AFP

Mourners of victims of the crashed accident of Ethiopian Airlines at the mass funeral in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, on March 17, 2019. Photo: AFP

Rescue personnel on October 29 searching the waters for wreckage from Lion Air Flight 610. Photo: AFP

Nurcahyo Utomo, the Indonesian National Transportation Safety Committee investigator, holding a Boeing 737 aircraft model during a press conference in Jakarta, Indonesia, on November 28, 2018. Photo: EPA

Boeing 737 MAX to return to China’s skies by ‘beginning of next year’ but more changes still needed

Before the 737 MAX was grounded in March 2019 after a second fatal crash, Boeing was selling one quarter of the planes it built annually to China buyers. Photo: AFP

Before the 737 MAX was grounded in March 2019 after a second fatal crash, Boeing was selling one quarter of the planes it built annually to China buyers. Photo: Reuters

How Everest disaster book Into Thin Air inspired craft beer maker Scott Powrie to push himself and climb a Himalayan peak

Jon Krakauer’s book Into Thin Air has had a big effect on co-founder of Hong Kong craft beer brand Double Haven and Dragon Water alcoholic seltzer,Scott Powrie. Photo: Scott Powrie

Jon Krakauer’s Into Thin Air (1997).

Vigne glacier with K2 and Broad Peak (right), which Powrie has climbed, in the background. Photo: Getty Images

Will Cantonese struggle to survive like Welsh, Hawaiian and Tibetan languages? Author predicts a rough road ahead

A man holds a sign professing his love for Cantonese at a rally in Hong Kong against the promotion of Putonghua, the northern tongue adopted in China as the national language. Photo: AFP

People wear traditional dress and carry the Welsh flag during a St David’s Day Parade in Cardiff in 2019. With a rise in Welsh pride has come renewed interest in the Welsh language, which the English repressed for centuries. Photo: Getty Images

A village school in China soon after the Communist revolution. The country’s new rulers “advanced an assimilatory language policy that previous Chinese rulers could only have dreamed of”, writes James Griffiths. Photo: Getty Images

Speak Not author James Griffiths.

The cover of Griffiths’ book.

Chinese science fiction’s diversity celebrated in stories of zombie apocalypse, migration in space and AI-human interaction translated into English

Xueting Christine Ni has translated 13 Chinese science fiction short stories for her new book. “There is now a mushrooming, an explosion of Chinese science fiction,” she says.

Chinese science fiction writer Han Song is among those featured in Sinopticon. Photo: Getty Images

The cover of Ni’s book.

Author Xueting Christne Ni. Moving to the UK at the age of 11 made her very aware of Chinese culture and that of her second home, she says. Photo: Xueting Christine Ni

Author advocates empathy yet for Trump he can find none, somewhat denting his argument about the power of stories and how to avoid being manipulated by them

Former US president Donald Trump at a recent rally. Photo: Sean Rayford/Getty Images

Academic Jonathan Gottschall says if we forget the stories our tribe tells and show people empathy, we won’t be manipulated. However, he can’t show any to former US president Donald Trump (above, right), likening him instead to Voldemort, the dark wizard of the Harry Potter books and films (portrayed by actor Ralph Fiennes, above, left). Photo: Getty Images

Jonathan Gottschall speaks at the 2015 Tribeca Film Festival in New York. Photo: Getty Images

A still from the Heider-Simmel experiment, a minute-long animation that illustrates the human tendency to create narrative from the most basic shapes. Photo: YouTube

The cover of Gottschall’s latest book.

Magazines

PostMag

Books

Travel

Lifestyle

Travel & Leisure

Culture

Business

Companies


Aviation reporter Peter Robison charts the hollowing out of a once-great engineering company by managers focused on narrow corporate self-interest and profit
Their cost-cutting, the firing of thousands of engineers and a disregard for safety led to the crashes of two brand new Boeing 737 MAX airliners, he writes



Decades before two Boeing 737 MAX airliners crashed in 2018 and 2019 the fall of the US plane maker had been set in train, and with it an increasingly wilful blindness to safety, writes aviation journalist Peter Robison.


Aviation

Plane crashes and aviation accidents

An assessment or critique of a service, product or creative endeavour.  Film reviews, restaurant reviews, reviews of art exhibitions. (Eg. Crazy Rich Asians: an important film, yes, but a good one?)


Review

Review | How decades of deskilling at Boeing doomed two 737 MAX flights – author dissects the death of its safety culture at the hands of corporate profiteers