bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Edmund Lee

3.5/5 stars
Philip Yung Tsz-kwong’s Where the Wind Blows is an artistically accomplished, genre-bending epic of the sort that is rarely attempted in Hong Kong cinema.
The writer-director takes the true-life stories of two of the “Four Great Sergeants” – the most notoriously corrupt police officers in 1960s and ’70s Hong Kong – and freely turns them into tragic heroes in a fever dream of gangland bravado, star-crossed romances and wartime trauma.
The film, which marks Yung’s first feature since 2015’s acclaimed Port of Call, may appear at times to be echoing Wong Kar-wai’s aesthetics with its slow-motion shots of smoking, repeated use of poetic onscreen texts, and sights of Tony Leung Chiu-wai pining for the one who got away.


But Where the Wind Blows offers so much more of everything else – from its sweeping historical scope to its ambivalent depiction of police corruption – that it is very much its own beast. This is a period biopic stapled to a crime thriller and decorated with a healthy sprinkling of history.
By adopting a kaleidoscopic structure for its decades-spanning narrative, this dual portrait of police sergeants Lui Lok (Aaron Kwok Fu-shing) and Nam Kong (Tony Leung) ceaselessly jumps between the two to cover everything from their beginnings in an era when graft was the norm, to their meteoric rise to power in the 1960s, to their final years in exile.

The hot-headed Lui is portrayed initially as an idealistic young man (played by Chui Tien-you) struggling to adapt to a culture in which everyone is on the take.
His subsequent rise through the ranks is ironically shown to be orchestrated by his resourceful Shanghainese wife, Tsai Zhen (Du Juan), who secretly pulls strings with the city’s organised-crime syndicates behind his back.
Nam is a wealthy young man (played by Lam Yiu-sing) who becomes a sharpshooter after he’s taken in by a Japanese commander during the war. His journey to becoming Lui’s fiercest rival in the police force is no less convoluted.
Leung’s charming delivery keeps things interesting, although the fine line between good and evil that his scheming character straddles is occasionally too vaguely drawn to be effective.

Regrettably, Where the Wind Blows is less interested in cataloguing the intricacies of their criminal activities than in contemplating their romantic heartbreak.
Lui’s marriage is marred by his longing for a girl (Jessie Li) he lost during the Japanese occupation of Hong Kong in the early 1940s, while Nam’s unconsummated desire for Tsai feels arbitrary at best.
As the stand-ins for the two other “Great Sergeants”, Michael Chow Man-kin’s seemingly righteous Bee and Patrick Tam Yiu-man’s duplicitous Yim leave only passing impressions.
Meanwhile, Tse Kwan-ho’s supporting role as the legendary drug dealer Ng Sik-ho, better known as Crippled Ho, is at once gripping and far too brief.

All of them are ultimately overshadowed by Michael Hui Koon-man’s scene-stealing turn as Independent Commission Against Corruption officer George Lee.
Hui only shows up in the 1970s-set scenes that bookend the film, but his powerful speech about the impact of corruption has likely done enough to make him a favourite in the best supporting actor race at the Hong Kong Film Awards.
In spite of its wildly ambitious approach to storytelling and stunning production values – the film does engross with scene after sumptuously staged scene throughout its 144-minute duration – there is something inaccessible about this sprawling and frequently brooding effort.

Its relative lack of narrative momentum, the repeated detours from the protagonists’ larger-than-life criminal careers, and their sometimes indecipherable motivations all combine to render Where the Wind Blows more of a visual feast for an art-house-inclined audience than the entertaining caper that mainstream viewers might have hoped for instead.
Want more articles like this? Follow SCMP Film on Facebook


Cut red tape to ease the pain of Hong Kong’s bereaved

How filming Four Trails, about 298km Hong Kong ultra run, was almost as hard as the race

The 12 best Asian films of 2024 ranked, from The Last Dance to All We Imagine As Light

The Prosecutor: Donnie Yen literally fights for justice in action-packed court drama

Asian cinema: Hong Kong film

Where the Wind Blows movie review: Aaron Kwok, Tony Leung play corrupt police sergeants in Philip Yung’s wildly ambitious period crime drama

Aaron Kwok in a still from Where the Wind Blows.

Aaron Kwok (left) and Tony Leung Chiu-wai in a still from Where the Wind Blows (category IIB; Cantonese), directed by Philip Yung Tsz-kwong, based on the true-life stories of two notoriously corrupt Royal Hong Kong Police officers.

Tony Leung as Nam Kong in a still from Where the Wind Blows.

Aaron Kwok as Lui Lok in a still from Where the Wind Blows.

Michael Hui as ICAC officer George Lee in a still from Where the Wind Blows.

Tony Leung (left) and Aaron Kwok in a still from Where the Wind Blows.

To My Nineteen-year-old Self movie review: Mabel Cheung documentary is an engaging, but deeply flawed, account of Hong Kong school life

A still from To My Nineteen-year-old Self.

A still from To My Nineteen-year-old Self, Mabel Cheung’s documentary that follows six Hong Kong secondary-school girls is noteworthy but flawed.

Ma Yin-yu in a still from To My Nineteen-year-old Self.

Say I Do to Me movie review: romantic comedy about social media and relationships from Beyond the Dream director is a high-concept dud

Sabrina Ng in a still from Say I Do to Me.

Sabrina Ng as Ping in a still from Say I Do to Me (category IIA, Cantonese), co-starring Chan Kin-long and directed by Kiwi Chow.

Chan Kin-long (left) and Sabrina Ng in a still from Say I Do to Me.

(From left) Mixson Wong, Candy Lo, Sabrina Ng, Isabel Chan and Jacky Tong in a still from Say I Do to Me.

Everything Under Control movie review: Hong Kong remake of Korean horror comedy, starring Hins Cheung and Ivana Wong, is wacky but not very witty

(From left) Michael Ning, Hins Cheung and Jeffrey Ngai in a still from Everything Under Control.

(From left) Michael Ning, Hins Cheung and Jeffrey Ngai in a still from Everything Under Control (category IIA, Cantonese), co-starring Ivana Wong and directed by Ying Chi-wen.

Juno Mak as Mr Lai in a still from Everything Under Control.

Ivana Wong (front) plays the leader of an eccentric village in Everything Under Control.

A Guilty Conscience movie review: Dayo Wong plays an acid-tongued lawyer in court drama showing Hong Kong filmmaking at its best

Dayo Wong plays acid-tongued lawyer in A Guilty Conscience, a court drama showing Hong Kong filmmaking at its best.

Dayo Wong plays an acid-tongued lawyer in A Guilty Conscience, a court drama showing Hong Kong filmmaking at its best.

Louise Wong (right) in a still from A Guilty Conscience.

Fish Liew in a still from A Guilty Conscience.

(Front, from left) Tse Kwan-ho, Renci Yeung and Dayo Wong in a still from A Guilty Conscience.

Sakra movie review: Donnie Yen in action-packed adaptation of Louis Cha’s epic wuxia novel Demi-Gods and Semi-Devils as tragic hero Qiao Feng

Donnie Yen as Qiao Feng in a still from Sakra.

Donnie Yen as Qiao Feng in a still from Sakra (category IIB, Cantonese), also directed by Donnie Yen. Chen Yuqi co-stars.

Kara Wai (front) and Cya Liu in a still from Sakra.

Donnie Yen in a still from Sakra.

Lifestyle

Entertainment

Arts & Culture

Culture

Film & TV

This story of Hong Kong police corruption in the 1960s and ’70s, starring Aaron Kwok and Tony Leung as corrupt officers, is an ambitious undertaking
Artfully shot with sumptuous scenes, it’s a sprawling epic that sometimes loses its plot momentum, focusing on the leads’ romances rather than their crimes


Aaron Kwok and Tony Leung star as corrupt Hong Kong police officers during the 1960s and ’70s in this sprawling crime drama from Philip Yung. Visually stunning, it sometimes loses momentum.


Chinese language cinema

Asian cinema

Film reviews

Cinema

Hong Kong cinema

Asian cinema: Chinese films

Fame and celebrity

Hong Kong celebrities and icons

Hong Kong culture

Hong Kong Film Awards

Crime in Hong Kong

Tony Leung Chiu-wai

An assessment or critique of a service, product or creative endeavour.  Film reviews, restaurant reviews, reviews of art exhibitions. (Eg. Crazy Rich Asians: an important film, yes, but a good one?)


Review

Review | Where the Wind Blows movie review: Aaron Kwok, Tony Leung play corrupt police sergeants in Philip Yung’s wildly ambitious period crime drama