bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

helpersCheckIsPostiesArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

moreOnThisArticles

urlAlias

commentCount

sponsorType

authorLocations

authors

paywallTypes

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

socialHeadline

headline

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

publishedDate

additionalInfoBoxes

images

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

createdDate

sponsor

factSheets

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

copyrighted

customTimezone

liveContents

Peter Gordon

A Few Planes for China: The Birth of the Flying Tigers
by Eugenie Buchan
ForeEdge
3.5/5 stars
The second world war created its fair share of myths: the “Flying Tigers” – a “small private air force that fought the Japanese over Burma and Western China”– became one of the first, providing as it did a few bright spots in the days after Pearl Harbour.
From December 1941 to June 1942, the force which “rarely had more than 40 airworthy planes” managed to take down almost 300 Japanese aircraft. A John Wayne film was released about their exploits as early as 1942.
Review: Cigarette Girl – love, cloves and enmity in post-war Indonesia
A Few Planes for China, a new book with the subtitle “The Birth of the Flying Tigers”, contains no instances of aviation derring-do; actual combat appears only in the last paragraph of the last chapter. But no matter. Eugenie Buchan has produced a well-researched and readable account of what – in retrospect at least – seems one of the more curious corners of American involvement in the second world war and one which bears some uncanny resemblances to the apparent conduct of conflicts of the present day.
Buchan is the granddaughter of one of the protagonists: “I came across a paper bag full of old files in a wardrobe in my parents’ home in Washington, DC. They belonged to my grandfather, Captain Bruce Gardner Leighton of the US Navy. The files revealed that he played a part in organising the Flying Tigers in 1939 to 1942 while he was vice-president of a long-forgotten aviation firm called the Intercontinent Corporation.”
The conventional narrative is that the Flying Tigers were primarily the creation of its legendary commander Claire Chennault (a character based on whom was played by Wayne in the 1942 film). A 1942 book stated that “Chennault created the Flying Tigers expressly to fight the Japanese regardless of whether Japan and the United States were officially at war or not”. This version has apparently never been seriously questioned.

Buchan writes: “The historiography of the Flying Tigers remains puzzling, Why, for over 70 years, have historians so rarely called into question a narrative spun by wartime propagandists and post-war apologists of the Nationalist cause?”
One reason, surely, is that one messes with Wayne at one’s peril. The conventional narrative is appealing; debunking myths of rough-hewn American individualism is often a thankless task. The more prosaic truth that Buchan teases out is altogether messier.
There is something of a “Pony Express” quality to the Flying Tigers, something that took considerable planning, had a certain mythical quality to it, tapped into American views of itself, but in the end didn’t actually operate very long.
Book review: The Borrowed – Hong Kong crime novel’s six episodes tell a compelling story about city’s history
More significantly, the Flying Tigers seem to have been born of commercial rather than strategic or military considerations. The planes in question were the Curtiss-Wright P-40s (“Tomahawks”) to which Intercontinent had exclusive Chinese rights. Intercontinent had also set up the Central Aircraft Manufacturing Company (Camco) to assemble planes in China. One thing led to another (the situation was, to say the least, complicated) and in meetings with the US Navy in 1940, Leighton “outlined how his company could create on strictly commercial lines combat units manned by Western pilots” based in Yunnan.
Buchan’s account is full of the fog of war. Both Britain and the US wished to support China as a bulwark against Japan, but neither wanted to actually provoke Japan into war. The three sets of bilateral relationships never coalesced into a single coherent strategy.
Book review: The Chinese Typewriter – a masterstroke of linguistic history
The Chinese government desperately wanted an air force that wasn’t, in the term they used for what currently passed for one, “rotten”, and took assistance whence it was offered. The USSR waxed hot and cold; there were even official trainers from Italy. American planes allocated to (and paid for) by Britain were – to Britain’s annoyance – sneaked off to China. American president Roosevelt seems to have been ambivalent about the entire exercise, as well he might have been. And, in Buchan’s main conclusion, “the man behind the Flying Tigers ultimately was Winston Churchill”.
It was the British who “saw the strategic importance … for the defence of their colonies in the Far East” who were key to turning the group “into a combat unit”.

There is something to be said for debunking traditional narratives, and the Flying Tigers tale is an illuminating window (if something murky can be said to be illuminating) into the run-up to US entry into the war.
But Buchan also calls Intercontinent “an early private military contractor”. It is hard to read this account and not be reminded of the problems caused by the conflating of private commercial and national security objectives in Iraq and Afghanistan. The Flying Tigers were made up of “volunteers”, most of whom just happened to have previously been with US armed forces; the US government denied having anything to do with it – a modus operandi that looks similar to more recent stories that have emerged from Eastern Ukraine.
Buchan clearly likes some of the protagonists more than others; the non-historian cannot second-guess these judgments, but they certainly make for interesting reading. The villain of the book seems to be Lauchlin Currie, whose “official title of ‘administrative assistant’ belied his influence”.
Book review: Black in China – tales of Chinese racism hint at Sino-African race relations, but fail to show the bigger picture
Currie, in Buchan’s account, was in effect running his own pro-China foreign policy, not infrequently at the expense of the British, causing confusion that required others to step in and clean up after him.
History may be made of personalities – Buchan gives us a raft of them – but it is less comforting when policy is forged by personality rather than rigour.
Asian Review of Books
Coming soon in Post Magazine: author Eugenie Buchan tells the story behind her book


North Korea suffers 1,100 casualties fighting for Russia, South Korea says

Ex-Israeli spies describe exploding devices operation against Hezbollah

Russia’s Putin holds talks with Slovakian PM Fico, in rare visit to Moscow by an EU leader

Israel’s Netanyahu vows to act with ‘force, determination’ against Yemen’s Houthis

War and conflict

Book review – A Few Planes for China: The Birth of the Flying Tigers unravels the myth behind legendary fighter pilots

Mechanics work on a Flying Tigers plane at Kunming, China, in 1942. Photo: SCMP

An air force serviceman shows a visitor an original plane used by the United States Flying Tigers air wing that operated against the Japanese in China during WWII and is now on display with other Military and Civilian aircraft at the China Aviation Museum, north of Beijing, China. The museum has over 300 aircraft on display and is built on an old air force base.

Madame Chiang Kai-shek, Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek, center, pose for a photograph with Flying Tiger Commander General Clair Chennault in this July 1942 photograph in unknown location. Madame Chiang Kai-shek, famous for using her beauty, charm and fluent English to lobby Washington to help China fight the Japanese and later the Chinese Communists, died Thursday, Oct. 23, 2003, in New York at age 105, Taiwan's Foreign Ministry said Friday. Details about the cause of death were not immediately available, the ministry spokesman Richard Shih said. (AP Photo/ Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, HO)

Book review: The Borrowed – Hong Kong crime novel’s six episodes tell a compelling story about city’s history

The leftist riots in Hong Kong in 1967 are the backdrop for the last of Chan Ho-Kei’s six novellas in The Borrowed. Photo; SCMP

Simon Chan Ho-kei, detective novel writer, poses for picture in High Street, Sai Ying Pun. 26JUL15

Cover copy of "13.67" by author Simon Chan Ho-kei. [11AUGUST2015 LIFE FEATURES]

The Borrowed book cover

Culture

Books

A John Wayne film in 1942 immortalised their exploits, and it was claimed they shot down almost 300 Japanese aircraft, but the authenticity of the Flying Tigers’ story is shrouded in doubt


An assessment or critique of a service, product or creative endeavour.  Film reviews, restaurant reviews, reviews of art exhibitions. (Eg. Crazy Rich Asians: an important film, yes, but a good one?)


Review

Review | Book review – A Few Planes for China: The Birth of the Flying Tigers unravels the myth behind legendary fighter pilots

A John Wayne film in 1942 immortalised their exploits, and it was claimed they shot down almost 300 Japanese aircraft, but the authenticity of the Flying Tigers’ story is shrouded in doubt