Advertisement

Macroscope | Debt ceiling crisis: can a US unable to put its financial house in order counter China overseas?

  • The debt limit stand-off poses implications for the world, as the uncertainty may bring a US recession that affects the country’s trade partners
  • For the US to play a more active role abroad economically, as China has, Washington must get its financial act together

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
5
US Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy (right) stands with Congressional Republicans during an event addressing debt ceiling negotiations with President Joe Biden outside the US Capitol in Washington on May 17. Photo: Reuters

The 19th-century Austrian statesman and diplomat Klemens von Metternich is credited with the saying, “When Paris sneezes, Europe catches a cold.”

Advertisement

This expression has, more recently, been applied to the United States and its implications expanded beyond Europe, to the entire world. The US’ economic and security decisions, including on trade and troop deployment, have, since the dawn of the post-war order, had implications beyond its borders. Unfortunately, this increasingly applies to its internal politics as well, which would not be nearly so disconcerting were its politics not so dysfunctional.

From the moment it became clear, in the fall of 2022, that control over US Congress would change hands, a few of us have been eyeing the upcoming debt ceiling showdown. Recent history – namely the showdowns over the debt ceiling that took place under a Democratic president and Republican-controlled House in 2011 and 2013 – suggested an upcoming confrontation.

It became even more pressing in January, when Kevin McCarthy’s gruelling effort to win the House speakership included concessions to Republican hardliners, which weakened his position and left him more vulnerable to their demands, including for steep spending cuts in return for lifting the debt ceiling via Congressional action.

This situation is not just of concern because the prospect of the US defaulting on its debts is so ominous – because there is no precedent for it, we can only speculate what default would mean, but no one thinks it would be good. It’s also worrying because previous showdowns over the debt limit went down to the wire, with Republicans initially demanding steep cuts, and the Democratic administration initially unwilling to budge, only for the two sides to hash out a deal just before the deadline.
Advertisement

Just the uncertainty created by this haggling resulted in the US facing its first-ever rating cut by Standard & Poor’s in 2011. The US has been haunted by the spectre of recession for most of the post-pandemic recovery, but has escaped – thus far. This time the uncertainty may seal a recession, and a default almost certainly will.

US president Barack Obama makes a statement to the press in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington on August 2, 2011. The US Senate approved legislation to avert a disastrous debt default and cut trillions in government spending, sending the contentious bill to Obama to sign into law. Photo: AFP
US president Barack Obama makes a statement to the press in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington on August 2, 2011. The US Senate approved legislation to avert a disastrous debt default and cut trillions in government spending, sending the contentious bill to Obama to sign into law. Photo: AFP
Advertisement