VAR a welcome move for football in Hong Kong
- The local game’s use of video technology will assist referees, but every effort must be made to ensure its introduction is smooth and that it enjoys the confidence of officials, players and – most of all – fans
Hong Kong football is preparing for a revolution, with the introduction of video technology to assist referees planned for next season. The move is overdue, but it will need careful planning and preparation.
Video Assistant Referee (VAR) systems have been gradually phased in around the world since 2016. They allow officials to study video replays to see whether the on-field referee has made a mistake. Certain key decisions may be reversed by the referee on the recommendation of a video assistant.
Singapore will use VAR for its premier league next year. It will be the 11th Asian country to do so. The system is used in elite European leagues and international competitions, including the World Cup.
Hong Kong must not be left behind. Players have to adapt their game to the higher levels of scrutiny provided by video replays. Hong Kong teams in international competitions will be better prepared if the system is also used for local games.
The city’s football association hopes VAR will raise refereeing standards, improve the conduct of players and enable Hong Kong to host major events. That would all be welcome.
But VAR has been controversial and divisive when introduced elsewhere. It is intended to reduce controversy over refereeing decisions and ensure fair play. Mistakes have, however, sometimes been made, even with the benefit of video evidence. Fans complain that the system slows down the game, while replays are studied, and those watching from the stands are sometimes baffled by decisions.
Hong Kong bosses target FA Cup final for VAR test, eye 2023-24 season for full use
The system is expensive, costing an estimated HK$12-15 million (US$1.54-1.92 million), with funding coming from the sport’s governing body Fifa and the government. Officials will require intensive training. Hong Kong only has two qualified VAR referees and will need many more.
Trials will also be important. There are hopes VAR will be tried out in the FA Cup final and key league games later this season. Officials must ensure they have complete faith in the system before it is allowed to influence decisions in such important games.
VAR is inevitable as it has become an essential part of the modern game. Every effort will be needed to ensure its introduction is smooth and enjoys the confidence of officials, players and – most of all – fans.
