Advertisement

Opinion | Preserving Fanling golf club’s natural beauty must be a priority in housing debate

  • Too many of Hong Kong’s environmental and cultural assets would be lost if part of the club grounds is given over to flats that would make only a modest contribution to solving our housing problem

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
8
The Fanling golf club offers a corner of woodland paradise in a city that sometimes seems like a concrete jungle. Photo: Yik Yeung-man

All through my almost five decades of working in Hong Kong, one simple rule of thumb has helped guide me a lot: if you don’t know for sure, go and see for yourself. It served me well as a reporter on The Star newspaper in the early 1970s, then as an investigator in the Independent Commission Against Corruption, and in various positions in the government from 1980 onwards.

Advertisement

What’s wrong with the freshwater stream serving Mui Wo? Go and investigate together with an engineer from Discovery Bay development. What’s the problem with the street lighting in a Lamma village? Go and look with some local villagers.

So when the Task Force on Land Supply considered whether all or part of the Hong Kong Golf Club in Fanling should be taken back for use as public housing, I did not jump to an immediate conclusion. I saw no immediate reason to care, although, in the interests of full disclosure, a company my wife owns is a paid consultant to the club.

After all, I am not a member of any golf club, and I do not play.

And at first blush, the Fanling club does not seem naturally deserving of sympathy. After all, its image for a long time has been of an old-fashioned sports venue with a whiff of being something of a colonial relic, a game played mostly by wealthy foreigners. And even if more locals are now engaging in golf, it’s still mostly for the rich elderly, right?

Advertisement
By contrast, the need for more land for housing is obvious and pressing. Micro flats, subdivided units – these are scandals that shame Hong Kong and call for urgent remedies. At a superficial level, it seems no contest.
loading
Advertisement