Advertisement

Distrust of Beijing is at the heart of Hongkongers’ opposition to extraditing fugitives to the mainland

  • Resistance in Hong Kong to the idea of transferring fugitives to the mainland stands in stark contrast to the openness to an extradition arrangement with Taiwan

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Guangdong police hand over three suspects, said to have been involved in a jewellery store robbery in Tsim Sha Tsui, to the Hong Kong police at the Huanggang Port in August 2018. Hong Kong does not allow the transfer of fugitives from its territory to the mainland. Photo: Edward Wong

Are human rights in the Philippines worse than in China? Yes, says Beijing loyalist legislator Paul Tse Wai-chun. Are Indians not as smart as Hongkongers? Alliance of Golfers convenor Kenneth Lau Ka-lok seems to think so. 

Advertisement
Tse last week ridiculed the opposition for fearing an extradition arrangement with mainland China, caustically noting that Hong Kong has a treaty with the Philippines too, which he claims has a far worse human rights record than China.
Lau mocked demands to use part of the Fanling golf course for housing, on a radio show last month, saying even India would not hold a public consultation on taking back sports grounds. He asked if Hongkongers were less wise than even Indians.
Corruption is endemic in the Philippines and the judiciary is politicised but its tattered democracy still enabled the recent release on bail of journalist Maria Ressa, who then freely resumed criticism of President Rodrigo Duterte.
The extrajudicial killings in Duterte’s war on drugs stains the nation’s human rights record, but so does China’s internment of a reported 1 million Muslim Uygurs.
Advertisement
Maria Ressa (centre), CEO and executive editor of online news site Rappler, displays her release order after posting bail at a court in Manila, the Philippines, on February 14. Ressa had been arrested by Philippine authorities on libel charges the previous day. Photo: EPA-EFE
Maria Ressa (centre), CEO and executive editor of online news site Rappler, displays her release order after posting bail at a court in Manila, the Philippines, on February 14. Ressa had been arrested by Philippine authorities on libel charges the previous day. Photo: EPA-EFE
Advertisement