Advertisement

Western media should rethink its distorted portrayal of China’s rise

L. K. Cheah says Western journalists who regard China’s motives with suspicion and cynicism are cherry-picking facts based on a biased view, and the misinformation they produce as a result is unhelpful

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
0
L. K. Cheah says Western journalists who regard China’s motives with suspicion and cynicism are cherry-picking facts based on a biased view, and the misinformation they produce as a result is unhelpful
The Western media can do everyone a favour by analysing China in a balanced way.
The Western media can do everyone a favour by analysing China in a balanced way.
Many in the West are alarmed by China’s rise as an economic power in just 30 years to become the world’s second-largest economy after the United States. Scores of Western writers have penned denigrating articles on China as they believe that a non-democratic country must be regarded with suspicion and fear. Although the “domino theory” of multiple countries succumbing to communism has fallen by the wayside, such writers continue to perpetuate a climate of anxiety and misunderstanding about the emergence of China.

Insecurities and bluster: the roots of distrust between China and the US

The latest to do so was Gideon Rachman in the Financial Times last month. He claimed that Xi Jinping ( 習近平 ) is taking his country in “radical and risky new directions” by abandoning the formula that has driven China’s rise. Specifically, he said Xi has significantly changed the three ingredients for success adopted by Deng Xiaoping ( 鄧小平 ) – in economics, politics and international affairs – and seeks to follow his own experiment for national rejuvenation. Xi, he said, has created a perilous path for the economy, fostered severe tensions within China, promoted a cult of personality for himself in the likeness of Mao Zedong (毛澤東), and caused confrontation with the West in the international arena.

Rachman is mistaken. On the economy, while it is true that China has had to make changes to its fiscal policies, Xi is dealing with the harsh realities of the global economic environment. He realises China cannot rely on export-led growth indefinitely, given the steady rise of costs and wages in China, and the fact that other countries can do things cheaper.

A man and his daughter ride down a street in Shanghai. China must follow a market-driven economy, or the continuing decline in exports could lead to disastrous high unemployment and social unrest. Photo: AFP
A man and his daughter ride down a street in Shanghai. China must follow a market-driven economy, or the continuing decline in exports could lead to disastrous high unemployment and social unrest. Photo: AFP

What’s holding back China’s consumption growth?

The move to a domestic consumption model, though perilous, is the consensus solution offered by most Western economists. Xi has little choice but to follow a market-driven economy, as the alternative is worse – the continuing decline in exports could lead to disastrous high unemployment and social unrest. To continue to rely on export-led growth would mean China having to devalue its currency, which would lead to a trade war with other exporting countries and trigger China-bashing by the US Congress (and perhaps even more strident measures by Donald Trump, should he become the next US president).

On the political front, many Western journalists claim Xi is building a cult of personality and has made himself into the most powerful Chinese leader since Mao. Xi has, the likes of Rachman say, used this power to launch his crackdown on corruption, resulting in thousands of convictions, causing widespread internal disquiet. Instead of praising Xi’s purge, his actions are disparagingly portrayed as terrifying much of China’s business and political elite.

For China to take its place among the world elite, President Xi Jinping must succeed in his attempt to root out corruption. Photo: AFP
For China to take its place among the world elite, President Xi Jinping must succeed in his attempt to root out corruption. Photo: AFP

Keep watch on your families, Chinese president tells cadres as he warns of ‘cabals and cliques’

The rampant corruption in China, where every business transaction has to be greased to close a deal, has to be one of the greatest weaknesses in China’s economy. Far worse, this aspect is symptomatic of a large chunk of society, where even promotions in the armed forces depend on payment to a higher-up authority. This pernicious syndrome makes for an unethical society and disrupts economic efficiency, given the large number of “middlemen” taking a slice of each transaction.

Xi should be praised for his courage and far-sightedness, not denigrated as a power-grabbing cultist opportunist
Advertisement