Advertisement

Hong Kong justice chief Teresa Cheng should have withdrawn from all unfinished arbitration work, sector veterans say

Post also learns embattled official gained government exemption to work on six ongoing cases citing their near completion as justification

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Secretary for Justice Teresa Cheng has been dogged by controversy since she took office on January 6. Photo: Winson Wong

Hong Kong’s freshly appointed justice minister should have withdrawn from all unfinished arbitration cases before assuming her new duties, sector veterans have said, arguing it would be hard to convince the public no conflict of interest existed.

Advertisement
The Post also learned that while Secretary for Justice Teresa Cheng Yeuk-wah requested a government exemption to authorise her work on six ongoing cases after taking office, she gave up other cases including at least one that had entered its final stage. Cheng cited the near completion of the six cases as her justification for the arrangement, which a seasoned arbitrator called “puzzling”.

Most of the legal professionals – each requesting anonymity over the sensitive issue – said they did not see any actual conflicts. However, they believed the public might form a “different view” about Cheng, who could be handling two roles the next few months.

Teresa Cheng must not remain blind to Hong Kong people’s high expectations of government officials

“[The public] may think she is spending Hong Kong taxpayers’ money on other people’s business,” a prominent arbitration figure said. Others cited worries that the ties she formed with the law firms involved in the six cases could pose challenges of impartiality as the city’s top justice official.

Cheng is expected to answer lawmakers’ questions at a justice and legal services panel hearing on Monday.
The justice minister, a former chairwoman of the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre, is now embroiled in a scandal over illegal structures at her home and a number of her properties in the city.

Industry leaders held mixed views on her integrity and how the scandal would affect the city’s arbitration landscape. While some concluded the controversy had inflicted a personal blow, others said it could create a ripple effect spreading across the sector.

Advertisement