Advertisement
Hong Kong

Hong Kong textbooks contain negative stereotypes on cultures and religions, researcher warns

'Most countries in the north' are developed, wealthy and free while 'southern countries' are poorer, with lower education levels, a lack of technology and more political censorship.

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
HKU professor Dr Liz Jackson has found prevalent stereotyping in liberal studies textbooks being used in Hong Kong. Photo: Bruce Yan
Shirley Zhao

"Most countries in the north" are developed, wealthy and free while "southern countries" are poorer, with lower education levels, a lack of technology and more political censorship.

No offence, Australia, but this is what a Hong Kong school textbooks says, according to a University of Hong Kong scholar researching the subject.

Stereotypes are more prevalent in textbooks than she expected, says Dr Liz Jackson, a social-science education specialist who has been researching secondary-school liberal studies textbooks for a year and a half.

Advertisement

"I've been surprised to find … a lot of negative stereotypes about Islam and … just a very simple way of discussing diversity," Jackson says. "This doesn't really increase understanding."

Some textbooks, when discussing ethnic minorities, say these people are all disadvantaged, poor and discriminated against. Others say different cultures cannot get along.

Advertisement
In the "Political Globalisation" chapter in Longman New Senior Liberal Studies, published by Pearson, two pictures - one of a Western woman in modern clothing and the other of a Muslim woman in a niqab, or veil, covering her face - are juxtaposed on the same page. The chapter features six pictures depicting Islam - all showing terrorists and extremists.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x