Advertisement

Letters to the Editor, August 5, 2017

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson in the South China Sea while conducting flight operations. Photo: AFP

Nations did recognise China’s claims

Advertisement
Eric Edwin Taylor (“Nations with claims want US Navy there”, July 31) should know why other claimants in the South China Sea welcome the presence of the US Navy. It is because they are the ones who began grabbing and militarising the islands in the South China Sea way back in the 1970s. Then China was poor and weak, and now that they find they are outplayed at their own game they run to the US for cover.

China drew up the nine-dash line in the 1940s. This was following its recovery of the South China Sea islands from a defeated Japan under the 1943 Cairo Declaration and the 1945 Potsdam Declaration which Japan signed as its instruments of surrender. Neither the US, the Philippines nor Vietnam raised any demur. That is, they did recognise China’s legitimate claims but then resorted to taking advantage of China’s weakness in the following years.

It is understandable that Mr Taylor is unaware of these facts. This is because they are rarely reported by the mainstream Western media, preoccupied as it is with spreading fake news on China and the South China Sea.

W. L. Chang, Discovery Bay

Advertisement

Too much carbon dioxide for one planet

I must take issue with Wyss Yim (“Wrong to see carbon dioxide as a pollutant”, July 22).
Advertisement