Advertisement

My Take | Hong Kong university students beat the drum for free speech, but only if you agree with them

Many of those who advocate the new political/democratic values are also behaving in ways that directly undermine or subvert them

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Protesters threw objects at police officers during riots in Mong Kok. Photo: EPA
Alex Loin Toronto

It’s a refrain we’ve heard time and again. We must not let Hong Kong become “just another mainland city” because our core values are what distinguish us from “them”, that is, mainland Chinese. Frankly, if we had the dynamism of some major mainland cities, we wouldn’t be doing so badly.

Advertisement

But the thing is, your core values are not necessarily mine. Even if we can agree on the same vocabulary , we don’t necessarily agree on the means to achieving the desired ends.

READ MORE: How Hong Kong’s first night in the Year of the Monkey descended into mayhem

For the longest time and until quite recently, our core values had meant entrepreneurship, free enterprise and our can-do attitude towards business and life in general.

Police officers walked past blazes set by protestors in Mong Kok. Some university student unions defended rioters as rebels and heroes fighting against government oppression. Photo: AP
Police officers walked past blazes set by protestors in Mong Kok. Some university student unions defended rioters as rebels and heroes fighting against government oppression. Photo: AP

Now, some people prefer to redefine our core values as the rule of law, freedom of speech and tolerance. They are what make us special. That’s all very well.

Advertisement

But what is troubling is that many of those who advocate the new political/democratic values are also behaving in ways that directly undermine or subvert them.

loading
Advertisement