Advertisement

My Take | Hong Kong protests expose the real rot in society

Something is rotten in the city of Hong Kong. That is what the pro-democracy rallies have exposed for the world to see.

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Lack of democratic governance is not the only thing driving people to the streets, or even the main one. Photo: EPA
Alex Loin Toronto

Something is rotten in the city of Hong Kong. That is what the pro-democracy rallies have exposed for the world to see.

Advertisement

Never mind that student leaders and the government will hold talks. They may or may not lead to minor concessions down the road for constitutional reform. There is certainly wiggle room to negotiate a more representative nominating committee. The protesters want full democracy, not a fake one. But lack of democratic governance is not the only thing driving people to the streets, or even the main one.

A 70-strong delegation of tycoons, business elites and professionals meet President Xi Jinping in the Great Hall of People. Photo: Xinhua
A 70-strong delegation of tycoons, business elites and professionals meet President Xi Jinping in the Great Hall of People. Photo: Xinhua
Many Hong Kong people are unhappy, but it's unlikely they were solely driven to fight police because they were upset by Beijing restricting the choice of candidates for the future chief executive. The pan-democrats may insist on that. But people say or do one thing and usually mean something more. It is the fact of widespread social discontent that should trouble our ruling elite. If you want a picture of what's rotten, visualise a recent newspaper front page which showed a group of ageing tycoons sitting in a semi-circle with President Xi Jinping while another photo depicted young student protesters.

That's the rich vs poor; the old vs young; the well-connected vs the disadvantaged; those who have power and others who are voiceless. It's a generational crisis, not just a political one. Extreme inequalities exist in education, job opportunities and social mobility. It's unclear whether they are caused by a lack of democracy, or whether they may be improved by "real" democracy. Such problems also exist in the most advanced Western democratic societies.

Since Beijing has insisted on a restrictive form of universal suffrage, our elites must now have the wisdom to consider wide-ranging reform in welfare, education, housing, medical services, labour mobility and training.

Advertisement

Think about allowing a more level playing field rather than monopolising key markets. Think less about the right to elect a chief executive and more about social entitlement. Think of the 1967 riots and the social reforms that the colonial Brits were forced to introduce.

Advertisement